What a Golf Swing Can Teach Us About M&A Deal Integration

Daniel McMahon • April 11, 2024

Key Takeaways

  • Like a golf swing, everything in a merger must be in alignment or else the deal, like a golf shot, will go horribly awry.
  • Consistency, focus, visualization, and follow-through are key to success in golf and M&A integration.
  • Being impatient and taking shortcuts can lead to hazards on the golf course or in the boardroom.

April 11, 2024 – With March Madness behind us, the sports world turns its attention to Augusta, Georgia for the annual Masters Tournament -- one of the four men's major golf championships in professional golf. The stunning greenery of the Augusta National Golf Club will have much of the Northern Hemisphere thinking about springtime and new beginnings. It’s also when Busy Season finally ends for accounting and tax professionals nationwide and thoughts turn to making things less painful and more efficient for the future, including joining forces with another firm.



So, what does golf have to do with merger and acquisition activity in the accounting world? It turns out, a lot more than you think. I’ve created an infographic that aligns the best swing tips I’ve received over my years of learning to golf with some select advice I’ve shared with clients about how to make their M&A process smoother and more successful. 

As legendary golfer Gary Player once said about the Masters: "Every shot is within a fraction of disaster -- that's what makes it so great." And that’s also what happens when two firms try to come together with vastly different cultures, client rosters and talent pools.

Like a golf swing, everything in a merger must be in alignment, or else the deal, like a golf shot, will go horribly awry. At the moment your ball is actually struck (i.e., the closing date), think of how many things need to be in motion for a golf ball to be hit successfully and to go straight down the middle of the fairway. You must have a backswing that is on plane, a consistent rhythm, and a really good follow through. Same goes for your pre- and post-merger game plan. If you’re on the M&A integration team, you must stay in rhythm and never lose focus. Because once you take your eye off the ball, things can break down quickly whether you’re on the golf course or in the M&A war room.

Swing tips and Integration Considerations

Outlined in the chart below are six key phases of a golf swing and six key points for consideration, which relate to the integration of a purchased accounting firm before and after the deal closing date. 

Don’t take shortcuts

Golf is not an easy game to learn; it’s even hard to master. One of the biggest mistakes I see golfers at all levels make is trying to take shortcuts. It takes practice, patience and resiliency (just like a firm merger). Inevitably you will hit a bad tee shot and find yourself behind a tree. A patient golfer knows you have to work yourself out of trouble one step at a time – one shot to get out from behind the tree and a second shot to get back on track. You “take your medicine” and live to play another day. But, too often I see players try to “save themselves” with one heroic shot even though the odds of making that shot are 2% at best. More often than not, they make things worse by bouncing off another tree, or winding up deeper in the rough, buried in a sand trap or sunk at the bottom of a water hazard. The same theory applies to an M&A transaction when both sides take short cuts or try to go too fast. As with a golf swing, a successful transaction must keep everything in rhythm and in sync.


Conclusion

I continue to learn the game and work on my own improvement as a player. My swing has evolved from my Dad informally teaching me how to swing a golf club in the backyard to developing lots of bad habits as a “do-it-myselfer.” 


I didn’t experience true results until I committed to learning how to swing a golf club like a true golfer. It wasn’t until I started to get coaching from a true PGA teaching professional that I found the discipline—and aligned the resources—to learn a golf swing the right way.

Likewise, a CPA firm leader who aligns with a trusted M&A advisor has a much better chance of seeing their M&A transaction go as smoothly as possible and find success in the newly combined firm. 


Do you have a favorite swing tip or M&A integration tip you’d like to add to the chart? I’d love to hear about it.

Please contact me at 877-442-4769, x701 | dmcmahon@integratedgrowthadvisors.com.

Daniel J. McMahon, a CPA and Certified Merger & Acquisition Advisor, is the Founder & Managing Partner of Integrated Growth Advisors (IGA), a value creation and growth advisory firm focused on empowering business leaders to systematically enhance their revenues, profitability, sustainability, and value. IGA creates sustainability and transferability—and wealth—for business owners by addressing common issues relating to growth, control, and transition of ownership. IGA has been serving clients throughout the United States since 2011.

By Dan McMahon, CPA, CM&AA December 16, 2024
With the college football playoffs set and the NFL season coming down the home stretch, there have been countless close games going down to the final seconds. The difference between winning and losing often has more to do with a team’s culture and preparation than it does with their pure talent. In the same way, most accounting firms have smart, conscientious, talented people at all levels of the organization. The difference between high performing firms and mediocre firms is that the high performers have the ability to stay in alignment and hold their composure when the pressure is on. While it’s easy to put your organization’s core values on the wall of your lobby or locker room, you don’t find out who has really bought into those values until the you-know-what hits the fan. Like elite sports teams and military units, high-performing firms stay together and stick to the game plan when faced with a big client loss, departure of a key employee, or busy season fire drills. Under the same circumstances, lesser firms throw in the towel, point fingers, and watch staff head for the exits. Sound familiar? Sun Tsu, the legendary general and philosopher of ancient times said, “Every battle is won before it’s ever fought.” In the heat of battle, I’ve found, you must think like a triage unit in combat. Casualties are all around you and coming in fast; you must treat the most serious life-threatening injuries before the ones that are merely painful – no matter how anguished the victim. In the heat of battle, you’re not going to get perfection. You must do the best you can with the people, resources and time you have to work with. As a leadership coach, I’ve noticed that firms with a strong culture and governance model are particularly well equipped to handle “battlefield” conditions. They tend to have four characteristics in common:
By Daniel McMahon November 29, 2024
December 4 2024 | 10 am PST / 1 pm EST
July 10, 2024
Dan McMahon contributed to the following article in Illinois CPA Society's Insight Magazine summer issue on the topic CPA firm M&A.
June 24, 2024
Check out Dan McMahon who recently appeared as a guest on Doug Noll’s Listening with Leaders podcast. Dan and Doug discuss the importance of listening as a leader, the art of improvisational theater performing, and why management teams must follow a parliamentary procedure for decision making.
By Daniel McMahon June 6, 2024
Key Takeaways
By Daniel McMahon June 4, 2024
See Dan McMahon’s latest article on Firm Governance Best Practices, which was published in the Summer issue of New Jersey CPA Magazine.
By Daniel McMahon March 16, 2024
A March Madness primer for corporate teams
By Daniel McMahon September 11, 2023
"Don't confuse firm governance with ESG"
By Gary Kravitz August 11, 2022
CPA firms nationwide are struggling to find the quality and quantity of staff needed to fulfill their ever-increasing workload demands. The failure to meet these necessary personnel levels has direct consequences on bottom line performance and client satisfaction. You would think that these extreme challenges would impact the methodologies and processes that firms utilize and cause them to change. Unfortunately, for many, this is not the case. It’s truly a question of insanity, doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. The following 7 actions are impediments to successful hiring today. CPA firms that follow these will proportionally lessen their level of success in attracting and hiring the resources they need.
More Posts
Share by: